Does this look familiar? photo © Paul Petrone
If you lived in Connecticut in 2011, chances are trees had a major impact on your life, in one way or another.
Between Tropical Storm Irene and the freak October snowstorm, if you didn’t lose a tree in your garden, you probably lost power when a tree, or part of a tree, fell on the power lines.
If a Tree Falls on a Power Line…
The impact of falling trees on power lines was so severe in our area that a report, Connecticut’s Street Trees: A Preliminary Analysis was prepared for Governor Malloy’s ‘Two Storm Panel’ that looked at how to mitigate the effects of future storms on the state.
The Connecticut’s Street Trees report was prepared by Jeffrey Ward, PhD, Chief Scientist, Forestry and Horticulture at CAES (Connecticut Agriculture and Experiment Station). The report extrapolated data on over 67,000 trees from 11 different cities in towns in Connecticut that had recently conducted an inventory of their street trees. My home town, Stamford, was one of the 11 cities.
The Report’s Findings
♦ It is estimated that there are over 1.1 million (yes, MILLION) street trees lining CT’s almost 21,000 miles of roads that are the responsibility of either your town, city or the state (depending on which roads they are located on) to maintain. No matter how you look at it, that’s a lot of trees.
♦ Almost half of those trees are maples. (Nutmeggers saw for themselves that most of the trees that came down in the October snowstorm seemed to be maples.) The problem with maples, according to the Ward’s report, is that “maples are more likely than other species to have structural defects such as weak forks and cavities that make them prone to failure from high winds, heavy snows and thick ice”. YIKES!
♦ Over half of Connecticut’s street trees are big — with a trunk diameter over 12″ — which means they are old. And the older a tree is, the more likely it is to fall down during a storm.
♦ Current maintenance standards call for pruning of the trees adjacent to power lines. But it was often the trees behind those adjacent trees or the trees across the street that caused lots of the damage.
The Report’s Recommendations
♦ Trees with “shorter mature heights” should be planted near power lines. That means trees that will grow to less than 25′ feet tall.
♦ Replace existing “maples with other species where there is a potential for future disruption of the electrical system”.
♦ Consider mandating that towns, cities and the state follow the recommendations by enacting municipal ordinances or even a state law.
More Recommendations
I spoke with Dr. Ward about his report for an article I wrote for an upcoming issue of Connecticut Gardener magazine. He shared some other thoughts on how Connecticut homeowners can help.
♦ Evaluate your existing trees and check for signs of damage from past storms, insects or other pests. If in doubt, contact a licensed arborist for advice on how to proceed.
♦ If you are planting a tree near a power line, don’t plant the trunk directly under the lines. Try to keep the branches of the trees about 8′ away from power lines.
♦ Don’t be afraid to plant large trees (those over 40′ tall), just don’t plant them near the street. If you are fortunate enough to have the space for a large tree, Ward suggests planting an oak (Quercus) or even one of our native maple trees, sugar maple (Acer saccharum) or red maple (Acer rubrum). (Planting maples is OK, just site them properly and watch them to make sure they stay healthy.)
♦ Prune your trees when they are young and their limbs are under 1″ thick. This way, you can do the pruning yourself (you’ll save some $$). Limb up trees to about 15′ off the ground. This will allow you to mow or walk under them and will help ensure the tree stay healthy for future generations.
Recommended Street Trees for Connecticut
White fringetree is a good choice for planting under power lines
Dr. Ward is working with Glenn Dryer of Connecticut College to compile a new list of recommended street trees for Connecticut. Old lists have trees that are too tall, susceptible to diseases, or, in the case of Callery pear, now considered potentially invasive. I’m looking forward to seeing the revised list once it’s available because it will undoubtedly impact not only what we will see on our streets but also in our nurseries.
So what should you do now if you need to replace a tree lost in a storm? Visit your local independent nursery and ask for recommendations for appropriate street trees for Connecticut that have a mature height of 25′ or smaller.
Or, check out my suggestions for small trees for Connecticut gardens.
Wow I am impressed that they are looking for solutions…the devastation of the oaks in MA was unbelievable from the October storm. I saw it when I drove to my sister-in-laws for Christmas. Almost every oak had damage. In newer areas where I live, they have begun to bury all the power, cable etc so no lines are visible and you don’t have to worry about power loss or tree issues…
Donna, I don’t think they had any other choice since the devestation from the trees was so widespread and so severe. The key will be how they respond to the report. Planting different kinds of street trees is a no-brainer but doing much needed pruning work or widening the pruning area so not just adjacent trees are pruned will cost major $$ and most likely will not happen as quickly as it should. But, we’ll see.
I hope they are consulting with people like you while compiling these lists. We became a little bit suspicious that kickbacks might have been involved…or perhaps it was only ignorance (more benign, but no less disappointing) when we obtained the list here a few years ago.
Ricki, It’s possible your street tree list was quite old and hadn’t been updated in a while. My sense is that CT’s hasn’t been updated for a decade or more. I have some clients in Larchmont, NY and a few years ago they must have updatd their street tree list to include redbud. Once homeowers saw what a lovely tree redbud is, they were all requesting to have a redbud planted outside of their homes.
Glad to hear people are being advised to replace their trees. It would likely be easier to not have trees at all but we would lose so much without them. When we started planting our new property with trees one of our concerns was the power lines, we tried to keep them at about 10 feet or more from the side of the road as I hate when power crews prune gaping holes into the sides of trees to make way for the lines.
Marguerite, The gaping-hole pruning happens here, too. Or, we have the half-a-tree-canopy pruning…either way it looks so ridiculous. Hopefully issuing new guidelines for street tree and their placement will eventually mean those misshapen trees will be a thing of the past.
[...] Because of its small size, ‘Winter King’ makes an ideal street tree. Just don’t plant it under, or too close to, utility [...]
The list of street trees was mentioned in the paper today, with a link to the Ag Station — http://www.ct.gov/caes/ShortTrees
[...] about the devastating impact trees have had recently on the lives of many Connecticut residents , Re-Thinking Connecticut’s Street Trees, I mentioned that work was being done on revising an outdated list of appropriate street trees for [...]